When it comes to bourbon, there’s a wealth of options at every price point, making it both exciting and challenging to build a great collection. After reviewing over 400 whiskies on the Film & Whiskey podcast, we've identified the best bourbons to buy across five price categories. Whether you're just starting out or are looking to add something special to your collection, we've got you covered.
The Rules
To guide our selections, we categorized bourbons into five price ranges:
- Under $25
- $25 to $50
- $50 to $80
- $80 to $120
- Over $120
Within each category, we evaluated bourbons based on flavor, complexity, and overall value. Our goal was to recommend the best bourbon in each price range, taking into consideration how well each bottle performs at its price point. We also included some honorable mentions that are worth considering.
The Picks
Under $25: Rebel 100
When it comes to bourbon under $25, Rebel 100 is a standout. “Rebel 100 is like a 15 out of 10 on value,” Brad notes, emphasizing its incredible quality for the price. At around $20, this bottle offers a rich, full-bodied bourbon experience with just the right amount of spice and sweetness. It’s a no-brainer for anyone looking for a reliable, budget-friendly bourbon.
Another strong contender in this category is Benchmark Full Proof, a 125-proof bourbon that’s also priced at $22. While it’s hard to beat the value of Rebel 100, Benchmark Full Proof deserves a mention for those who prefer a higher-proof option.
$25 to $50: Cooper’s Craft 100 and Rebel Distiller’s Collection
In the $25 to $50 range, we found ourselves spoiled for choice. After some debate, two bourbons emerged as top picks: Cooper’s Craft 100 and Rebel Distiller’s Collection. “Cooper’s Craft 100 is slept on,” Bob mentions, noting its excellent quality for the price. This bourbon is not only a great sipper but also makes fantastic cocktails, making it a versatile addition to any bar.
Rebel Distiller’s Collection, on the other hand, is Brad’s top pick. “It takes everything you get with Rebel 100 and shows you why that is so good when you give it a higher quality edition,” he says. At around $45, this bottle offers a more refined version of Rebel 100, with deeper flavors and a smooth finish.
Honorable mentions in this category include Jack Daniel’s Triple Mash and 1792 Full Proof. Both of these are excellent choices, but ultimately, Cooper’s Craft 100 and Rebel Distiller’s Collection offer the best balance of quality and value.
$50 to $80: Woodford Reserve Double Oaked
In the $50 to $80 range, Woodford Reserve Double Oaked stands out as a must-have. “Woodford Double Oaked was the first whiskey I ever had that made me step back and go, ‘Oh, that’s what whiskey can be,’” Brad recalls. This bourbon delivers a rich, layered experience with notes of vanilla, caramel, and toasted oak. It’s a favorite among whiskey enthusiasts and a great introduction to more complex bourbons.
Other contenders in this range included Green River Full Proof, Old Forester 1910, and Wild Turkey Rare Breed. While these bourbons are all excellent, Woodford Reserve Double Oaked remains the top pick for its unique flavor profile and overall impact.
$80 to $120: Barrell Vantage
When it comes to the $80 to $120 category, Barrell Vantage is the clear winner. “Barrell continues to be the greatest blender of whiskeys of any company we’ve ever encountered,” Bob says. Priced at around $90, Barrell Vantage offers a beautifully balanced bourbon with an array of complex flavors that showcase the skill of the blenders at Barrell Craft Spirits. It’s a top-tier bourbon that’s worth every penny.
Honorable mentions include the Pursuit United Bourbon and John J. Bowman Single Barrel, both of which are excellent choices. However, Barrell Vantage’s superior blend and depth of flavor make it the standout in this category.
Over $120: Blanton’s Straight from the Barrel
For those looking to splurge, Blanton’s Straight from the Barrel is our top recommendation in the over $120 category. “It was, no joke, the best bourbon I’ve ever had in my life,” Bob says of his experience with this whiskey. Bottled at barrel proof, this bourbon offers an intense, concentrated flavor that’s unmatched by most other bourbons. If you’re willing to spend the money, Blanton’s Straight from the Barrel is a remarkable choice.
Other high-end options include Bardstown Amrut Collaborative Series and Old Forester 150th Anniversary, both of which offer unique and luxurious experiences. However, Blanton’s Straight from the Barrel remains the top pick for its exceptional quality and flavor.
Conclusion
Building a bourbon collection doesn’t have to break the bank. With options ranging from the budget-friendly Rebel 100 to the luxurious Blanton’s Straight from the Barrel, there’s something for every whiskey lover at every price point. Whether you’re new to bourbon or a seasoned aficionado, these picks offer a great starting point for exploring the rich and diverse world of bourbon whiskey.
We’d love to hear your thoughts! What are your go-to bourbons at each price point? Join the conversation on our social media channels and let us know your favorites. For more whiskey reviews and recommendations, be sure to check out the Film & Whiskey podcast. Cheers!
