Introduction
Today, we’re diving into Hardin’s Creek Colonel James B. Beam Bourbon Whiskey, an exciting release from Jim Beam’s new line of annual offerings. Launched in 2022, this whiskey is distilled at the Fred B. Noe Distillery and crafted by master distiller Freddie Noe. At just two years old and bottled at 108 proof, it aims to honor Jim Beam’s legacy with a low distillation proof and lower barrel entry proof. While the story is compelling, we had questions about how well a two-year bourbon could deliver on flavor. Here’s our full breakdown.
This review is taken from our episode "District 9 / Hardin's Creek Col. James B. Beam." Click the link to listen to this review in audio format.
Nose
Brad: The nose opens with notes of peanut brittle and vanilla frosting, offering some sharply sweet characteristics. Black pepper adds a touch of spice, but the young graininess holds it back. 7/10
Bob: I found floral notes like rose petal and melon alongside oak, black pepper, and vanilla. While the aromas are appealing, they feel muted, which keeps me at a 7.5/10.
Taste
Brad: The palate is muted, with light caramel and vanilla up front before transitioning into bold black pepper, oak, and even a paprika spice. The youth of the whiskey is evident, and I’m landing at 6/10.
Bob: This bourbon tastes surprisingly oaky and aged for its two years, with green apple, caramel, and classic Beam nuttiness. However, the toasted oak profile, while interesting, lacks balance. It’s one of the best young bourbons I’ve had, earning a 7.5/10.
Finish
Brad: The finish brings oak, coffee bean, and black pepper. Unfortunately, the youthful sourness lingers, keeping it at a 6.5/10.
Bob: The finish reveals a minerality akin to chalky bottled water, overshadowing the bourbon’s more enjoyable elements. For me, this is a 6/10.
Balance
Brad: The whiskey doesn’t offer enough complexity or cohesion to feel balanced. The sour grain notes overshadow the experience, so I’m giving it a 6/10.
Bob: The proof saves this whiskey from feeling too watered down, but the lack of a consistent throughline hurts its balance. 7/10
Price
Brad: At $80 for a two-year bourbon, this feels overpriced. I’d value it closer to $40, and for that reason, I’m giving it a 3.5/10.
Bob: The quality of the liquid doesn’t justify the premium pricing, especially with Jim Beam offering better options at lower costs. I’m at a 4/10.
Final Scores
Bob: I’m at a 32/50 overall. While the liquid itself isn’t bad, the price tag drags it down significantly.
Brad: My final score is 29/50, reflecting the whiskey’s lack of sweetness and its overwhelming youthfulness.
Average Score: 30.5/50
Conclusion
While Hardin’s Creek Colonel James B. Beam delivers some interesting moments, its youth and price point keep it from being a strong recommendation. With a final score of 30.5/50, we’d suggest trying a pour at a bar before committing to a bottle—or exploring other Jim Beam offerings at lower price points.
FAQ
1. How much does Hardin’s Creek Colonel James B. Beam cost?
The average price is $80, which many consider high for a two-year bourbon.
2. What does Hardin’s Creek Colonel James B. Beam taste like?
Expect notes of oak, black pepper, and caramel with a youthful grainy character.
3. Is Hardin’s Creek Colonel James B. Beam worth buying?
At its current price, it’s hard to recommend. Consider trying a pour at a bar before purchasing.
4. What’s the proof and age of Hardin’s Creek Colonel James B. Beam?
This whiskey is 108 proof and aged for two years.
5. What is unique about Hardin’s Creek Colonel James B. Beam?
Crafted at the Fred B. Noe Distillery, this whiskey emphasizes low distillation proof and showcases the potential of young bourbon.
