Introduction
We’re excited to dive into Jack Daniel’s Triple Mash Blended Straight Whiskey, one of the newer expressions from the iconic Jack Daniel's distillery. Alongside their Bonded release, this whiskey brings a unique blend of three bottled-in-bond whiskeys: 60% Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Rye, 20% Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Whiskey, and 20% Jack Daniel’s American Malt. Clocking in at 100 proof and retailing around $35-$37, it’s positioned as a versatile, more refined take on the Jack Daniel’s we all know. Let’s break it down and see how it stacks up.
This review is taken from our episode "Taxi Driver / Jack Daniel's Triple Mash." Click the link to listen to this review in audio format.
Nose
Bob: There’s a dusty, peanut-like quality here that really reminds me of my elementary school gym—kind of a shoe-scuffed-floor vibe. But underneath that, you get classic Jack Daniel's caramel and some nice fruit notes like green apple and peach. It’s really taking me back. 8/10
Brad: I agree, Bob. It’s got a sweet, refreshing nose with that green apple upfront, a bit of peach, and some dusty peanut rounding it out. It’s intriguing. 7.5/10
Taste
Bob: This tastes like breakfast—waffles with peanut butter, maple syrup, and a side of fresh apple slices. It’s got this autumnal vibe, like a stack of pancakes on a crisp morning. I’m loving it. 9/10
Brad: The peanut and apple stick around, with a hint of cinnamon and caramel joining the mix. It’s a really refreshing pour, and I’m with you, Bob. This could be the perfect summer whiskey. 8/10
Finish
Bob: The finish doesn’t quite hold up to the nose and palate. It’s a bit thinner, and there’s a touch of oak bitterness that comes through. Still, it’s solid overall, just not as impressive. 7.5/10
Brad: I think the lack of viscosity holds the finish back. It’s short, sweet, with some oak and apple, but nothing too exciting. I’d say it’s fine, but it’s not hitting the heights of the initial taste. 6.5/10
Balance
Bob: Despite the weaker finish, this whiskey is extremely well-balanced. It’s an easy sipper that I’d recommend to anyone moving up from an 80-proof whiskey. There’s a nice harmony between the fruit and peanut notes, and the burn is minimal. 9/10
Brad: For me, it’s good, but it doesn’t have the complexity I was hoping for. The flavors are enjoyable, but I wouldn’t call it layered or deep. Still, it’s well put together. 7/10
Value
Bob: Here’s where things get tricky. When I bought this for $34, it felt like a steal, but now that it’s jumped to $37, and considering it’s a 700ml bottle instead of the usual 750ml, it feels slightly overpriced. That said, it’s still a great whiskey. 8/10
Brad: At $37, it’s creeping up in price. If it were $33, I’d be all in. But it’s still worth buying for what it offers. 7/10
Final Scores
Bob: I’m coming out to a 41.5/50 on this one. It’s an impressive whiskey that punches above its price point. I’d say buy a bottle without hesitation.
Brad: I’m a bit lower at 36/50, but it’s still a fun, intriguing whiskey worth keeping on your shelf. At the price, it’s a solid addition to your collection.
Conclusion
With an average score of 38.75/50, Jack Daniel’s Triple Mash is a great pick for those looking for a well-rounded whiskey experience at an approachable price. It’s an easy recommendation for a bottle purchase, especially if you’re a Jack Daniel’s fan looking to explore something a bit more refined. While it might not be the most complex pour out there, it delivers on balance and flavor in a way that’s well worth its cost.
If you're looking for a bottle that sits just under the 40/50 mark, it’s a solid investment. But at its price, we’d suggest skipping the bar pour and grabbing the full bottle instead. You won’t regret it!
